baritonewithtenortendencies said: "There's a difference between singing a part and being a part "
Definitely! I have always felt that Claire Moore and Judy Kuhn (both amazing singers) were never really a Christine or Cosette. They might be called a (mezzo) soprano because they reach the notes, but they never became the part or sounded like the right voice type to me. Their head voice just does not sound like a (mezzo) soprano. A Christine (mezzo soprano) sounds like a Sarah Brightman or Joke de Kruijf to me. There is also a 3rd category, which I call the belt-soprano, Celinde Schoenmaker and Sierra Boggess, trying to belt every note in between where they can because they are not really soprano's, even though their head notes do sound like it sometimes.
I would call Lea Salonga and Olivia Newton John mezzo soprano's but I believe Lea calls herself an alto?
Also, I think voices are unique. For example, Sam Harris and Anthony Warlow are both considered tenors. I think Sam Harris is a great singer, but it does sound like female vocal chords that went through testosterone/puberty, the opposite of Warlow. They should not both be in the same box "tenor".
Updated On: 12/5/23 at 09:22 AM