Saw it tonight from the mezzanine...I came out humming the LED's.
I'm one of those rare people that did not see the movie, so I came in with no preconceived notions of what it should or shouldn't be.
I found the group numbers to be over amplified to the extreme and they need to have a musical rehearsal, to get EVERYONE enunciating, the openings of both Act I and Act II could have been sung in (insert any foreign language) because I understood nothing of either of them. The ballads, duets and trios were slightly better, but still at times, unintelligible. The orchestra needs to be the support, not the star of these numbers.
I wish I could say I thought the two leads were great...but...I think they served the script and that was about it. Neither was terribly charismatic to me, and Molly in particular left me cold. She did do a lovely job with the ballad near the end of Act I, but up to that point I wasn't buying what she was selling.
Oda Mae...hmmmmm. Disappointing vocally, for me. She has two rousing numbers one being the 11 o'clock number...which should have stopped the show. It didn't. I thought she was pretty good in the scenes and got all the comedy out of them. But again, not a spectacular performance.
The set and effects steal the show and not always in a good way. One effect in particular distracted me so much that I found myself not paying attention to the scene that followed it, because I was still trying to figure out how it was done. The set seems to be in nearly constant motion...and the use of the LED's is pretty amazing, and nicely synchronized with the live action, for the most part. But there are times, it is more of a distraction than an asset.
For me the most memorable song on the evening was "WITH YOU" - it was simply sung and has some lovely lyrics. But the rest seemed mediocre at best.
Choreography....the less said the better. It's truly mundane stuff.
All in all...if I were ranking it...I'd give it a 6.75 out of 10. Not the worst thing I've ever seen...but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone...especially at full price. Wait until it's at TKTS.
"Just a Guy. Your feelings are touching. I am gladdened by the thought that you will one day wind up 6 feet under as we all do." - MrRoxy ------
"I do not suggest you walk out the door onto a New York street with your vulnerable child part exposed and not protected..." - Jason Bennett