These are all well and good, and in every case you'll leave the theatre thinking, "Y'know, that was amusing -- WAIT A SECOND! I BLEW OVER A HUNDRED BUCKS ON THAT?????"
Do yourself a favour and check off-Broadway. The shows are just as entertaining and far cheaper. Right now, there's a great little two-man show called GUTENBERG THE MUSICAL that's running off-B in prep for a Broadway move probably next season, so you can see Broadway-caliber work at about half the price. And it's howlingly good fun.
There are all kinds of options out there. Dont feel you have to restrict yourself to theatres between 41st and 54th to find a good time.
http://docandraider.com