Thank you guys for the responses!
I second Citizen M. Rates vary, but the rooms are cool (cruise ship in the city-type vibe) and the rooftop bar is great (and open only to hotel guests). The Michelangelo sometimes has great weekend rates. I also love the Algonquin, which is more of a splurge but can also have good weekend rates. Plus, for a theatre buff, it's ground zero.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/31/18
I stayed at the Ameritania last trip, it was probably the best out of the ones I have stayed apart from the more expensive ones in Chelsea..
It was very reasonably priced, the rooms were clean and a decent size, the staff were great and the location was excellent!
I always book through Expedia because I get flights as well, but here's their website anyways x
https://ameritanianyc.com
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/15/15
I stayed at The Pod on 42nd street last time I stayed in the city. My favorite place to stay is in Long Island City at the LIC Hotel. Super nice,clean and fairly cheap.
Videos