Just got home. As I said, LOVE the new leads.
I really love Will Chase as a performer, and still maintain that he is one of most versatile musical theatre actors working today. He does an excellent job as Shakespeare, definitely putting his own personal energy into his portrayal. I'm not sure if he's giving a Tony-worthy performance like Borle undoubtedly was, but he's still great in the role, and as I said, I just love him as a performer.
Josh Grisetti is lovely and perfect for the role. I think he's plays Nigel a little less nervous and fidgety than Cariani, but it works.
Kritzer is Kritzer, of course. She's flawless, though underutilized (as the role is written, unfortunately).
Catherine Brunell really impressed me. I loved her dorky energy. She reminds me of a young Rachel Dratch. I had never heard of her before this, but I'll have to keep my eyes open for her in the future.
Rob McClure is doing a great job as well. I think he fits the role better than BDJ, though I like BDJ more as a performer in general.
(Wow, I used the word "role" a lot in this post!)
I suppose I exaggerated a bit in my last post. There are lots of moments I find funny throughout the show, and I do think Nigel and Portia are funny, in addition to Shakespeare. The show overall is not for me, though. Still, I'm happy for their success, and glad so many enjoy it (no snark intended).