I didn't love it enough to stage door it, but very intrigued who is stage-dooring, please let me know.
I also went to Maybe Happy Endings and was wondering if Darren Criss stage-doors.
I did stage door at Mattress and only Michael Urie-who was super nice and a couple more actors went to greet fans, but Sutton Foster and Will Chase didn't stage door. I wanted to meet Will Chase and no luck.
"People have their opinions and that doesn't mean that their opinions are wrong or right. I just take it with a grain of salt because opinions are like as*holes, everyone has one".
-Felicia Finley-
Not sure about Nicole, but Darren Criss has been stage-dooring most (if not all?) nights, though I think he comes out a little later than the rest of the cast.
The night I was there, one of the non-Nicole leads had done a quick, sneaky exit from what seemed like the theater lobby itself, wearing a hoodie and sweats - and was a few steps ahead of me as I exited the theater from the mezzanine as an audience member. They went unnoticed to 8th Avenue, lowered their hoodie and walked across the street like a normal New Yorker wherever they were going. Smooth