ladypresent, I'm curious about one thing here. I either haven't seen or have no interest in seeing most of the shows you mentioned. (Exceptions on your list: Beautiful, which I saw last year on tour and thought was OK but unmemorable, and Ain't Too Proud, the Temptations musical, which I'm seeing in Berkeley next month.) Disney shows have been on Broadway for nearly two decades. Musicals aimed at families with young kids have been around a lot longer than that. Bio/jukebox musicals come in waves. No one is requiring you to see any of those musicals.
Don't want to see Charlie and the Chocolate Factory? Me neither. But what have you seen and liked? Are you actually refusing to see other Broadway musicals because On Your Feet! ran for a couple of years? If so, you've missed some interesting shows.
And if Broadway musicals are getting you down, what about off-Broadway? What about plays? As has been pointed out, most everything on Broadway is an adaptation of something. West Side Story was just Romeo and Juliet in a modern setting, with songs and dances. The history of Hello, Dolly goes back more than a century before it opened, including a play that ran less than a decade before the musical version. The King and I was adapted from a memoir. Carousel was adapted from a play. Show Boat invented the modern musical. But Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein based the whole thing on a bestselling novel.
I'm not comparing Spongebob to any of those shows, but they are all just adaptations. Some are based on familiar material, others more obscure. Some elevate the material they're based on, with terrific new songs and performances, and others don't.
The only real difference is that you have no interest in some of it. But you can vote with your feet, and your wallet.
Updated On: 10/1/17 at 04:09 AM