I had seen this on stage and felt that I didn't really "get it"; the most interesting part to me was about the 4 turnings. Watching it again during an actual "crisis" does draw out different parts of it though, and I think there was more for me to discover in the earlier half (which I thought dragged on and was unnecessary in my original viewing). I don't know if I'm necessarily convinced that it "deserved" to be a Pulitzer finalist or get all the hype, but I do think getting the script would be an interesting read. Maybe it's just a slow burn kind of a piece for me *shrugs*
I thought they did a pretty great job setting the mood and ambiance, though, given the limitations of Zoom (the green border was a little distracting, as was the switching around of positions). But for just acting in front of a camera in an empty room, I thought the actors gave excellent performances, even if you lose the physicality of their motions.