Jordan, I've seen many plays. I listed in this thread that I saw (and hated) Is He Dead?, The Little Dog Laughed, and Race. You can see that in one of my posts here.
I've also seen wonderful plays like Glengarry Glen Ross, Tru, and The Gin Game.
It's just the last three plays that I saw that made me feel like never seeing a play again. One disappointing play after another (on top of the expense) makes you feel that way.
I don't think it's odd or immature to base my feelings on my recent unfortunate play-viewing history.
Mimi, since you are going on Saturday maybe you can catch Tenor. They do have a rush policy and someone on the board commented they got seats close to the stage, I believe row B to the side. Or you can check the TKTS booth to see what they have available.