Okay, time for big sister to jump in and let everyone know that my sister is not nuts!
I went to this show with her havning already heard the OBCR many many times and I was pretty shocked when the "lover" came out and didn't say/sing a single word. Since he not only didn't sing, but his lips weren't moving, I figured that maybe this part is not in the show. Having now read the comments about it being a recording, I guess there was some glitch, but his lips never even moved, so maybe he knew about it in advance? It definitely didn't make as much sense without it but you could get the idea.
Bottom line is we were there, we didn't miss it, it simply didn't happen for whatever reason. We're going back in a couple of weeks, hopefully all will go well that day and we will hear the part about the green elixir. :)
"I wrote a book: "How to Be Popular". Now I've put together a top ten list of how to help you:
-Elphie, everyday... shower. I mean, who knows? Maybe some of that green is gonna come off!
-Deodorant Elphie. No body likes a stinky witch!
-I think we've covered the hair, we'll get to that.
-Clean underclothes. That's all I'm gonna say.
-Look at your posture. That's no way to be popular!
-Bed made, room straightened. We've done that.
-Colors blended. Oookay.
-But the most important thing to have, to make yourself popular, is to keep your beautiful smile."
~Kristin Chenoweth in her last performance of the song "Popular"