It's official? AfterElton.com's 37 Hottest Guys in Theater — Page 3

LOL, this thread


I'm gonna add Idina Menzel to this list of hottest girls
I mean, I'm straight, but I seriously think she's gorgeous :)

and DEFINITELY seconding Laura. Woman is so freaking stunning



OH and I just now realized the lack of Brian d'Arcy James up on the actual list! Not cool. I lurve him <3 And Adam and Anthony could use some love toooo

---

Updated On: 1/29/09 at 11:14 AM

I miss TRAILER PARK. That was such a great show.

---

I wish people would read the list. They're not including chorus boys, which is why Spencer Liff, etc aren't part of the list.

I'm surprised they didn't add Christopher J. Hanke over some of those people. I'm also surprised Nick Adams made the list considering he's pretty much just a chorus boy, right? I guess he had a "part" in "A Chorus Line," but still.

And Leah Anne Larkin to the hottest girls list. Def.

I wouldn't kick Cady Huffman outta bed either (pre-lesbo haircut).

---

Wanna Be A Foster - I miss it too. It closed far too soon.

"Kelly-Orfeh is stunning, but far from the "hottest woman in theatre"! For lack of a better way of saying it she is a little old and "chunky" for my and i am sure other's tastes."

Chunky? Um, are we talking about the same Orfeh? Girl is TINY, and totally ripped. And I dunno, I've seen photos of her back during her Or-N-More days (in 1991), and she looks the same facially as she does now. She ain't old. She doesn't AGE.

"Just once, I would love to see a thread full of Broadway performers critiquing Message Board users' bodies, using words like chunky and a little old, etc. I'm sure other descriptive adjectives would come into play."

For real.

---

Updated On: 1/29/09 at 11:25 AM

Piragua-like this... :P


jrb-I can tell you that at least I know that I am neither chunky nor a little old, but I can't talk for others here

Kelly-As I just mentioned I am young and lean and more attracted to a young petite girl... I do think Orfeh has gotten "hotter' in more recent years and yes she is ripped, but based off of the pic from Trailer Park, she is not as petite as I find attractive (Same as others here commenting that Aaron Lazar wasn't there type...)

"Kelly-As I just mentioned I am young and lean and more attracted to a young petite girl... I do think Orfeh has gotten "hotter' in more recent years and yes she is ripped, but based off of the pic from Trailer Park, she is not as petite as I find attractive (Same as others here commenting that Aaron Lazar wasn't there type...)"

Well, to be fair, she is MUCH tinier in recent photos than in that Trailer Park shot? I just prefer women (and Orfeh, I guess) with a little more meat on their bones :) Stick-skinny girls really just don't do it for me!

http://i515.photobucket.com/albums/t359/starfishkelly/Orfeh/Picture2-3.png

---

Then say, "She's not my type".

Do NOT say that a woman who is NOT chunky is chunky just because you like petite girls. And even if she was chunky, you don't find comments like that rude?

This is a PUBLIC message board.

---

Well, everything else aside, I think it can at least be said that Orfeh and Andy are the hottest Broadway couple, by far.

I mean, come on!

---

I’m a straight female too, but would definitely put these people on the girls’ list:
Laura Benanti
Leigh Ann Larkin
Kate Shindle
Tracy Jai Edwards

^All so beautiful!
And just because I’m fans of them and think they’re pretty too:
Kristin Chenoweth
Annaleigh Ashford
Sierra Boggess
Haven Burton
Sutton Foster
Orfeh

Tracy Jai is definitely sexy too. She's got a killer body!

---

I second Hugh Panaro. And I also have a bit of a crush on David Pittu.

---