I thought it was meh and in no way an improvement over the brilliant original.
But it wasn't a disaster either. Fragmented mess, but not a disaster and a hot mess worth seeing for most people. I recommend it.
If you're a hard-core like me, spare yourself, save your pennies, and go see the original London production (now featuring "dynamic" new orchestrations, blah) or better yet the Japanese production (which uses the originals of everything, yay!). Oh how I love my Japanese friends.
EDIT: As for Gavey's croaking scene, it's already a devastating moment no matter what. The NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! was comical to me, I'm sorry to say. The entire show was filled with similar over-the-top performances. It wasn't the casts fault at all and I loved them all. You could tell the directors told them to infuse the piece with "passion" and it would have worked had they actually instructed them to inject passion as opposed to "cheese," which is what this production dialed up to 10.
I just about laughed when during "Empty Chairs at Empty Tables" Grantaire and Gavroche appear next to Marius with literally sad puppy dog faces. It's small stuff like that which may not seem like a big deal alone, but when combined in many similar instances, make an evening where you're told what to feel, how to feel it, and exactly when. This Les Mis was desperate to make you forget about its superior original version which was brilliantly suggestive, subtle, and powerful.
Go see this newest version for the cast who are absolutely top notch. Yes, there is some miscasting but nothing disastrous. The new "dynamic" (according to its director) doesn't ruin it, either. It can get irritating though, especially during late in the second act when the show naturally settles and moves at a slower pace--the screaming and wild gestures come off as just extremely desperate. For example, "Drink With Me" is by its very nature a reflective, contemplative moment. The directors did not care and made it into a chummy "woo-hoo we're FRIENDS!!! *group hug* moment. Even the first line was sung with an explosive upbeatness "DRINK with me!!!!" It was really lame.
Recreation of original John Cameron orchestration to "On My Own" by yours truly. Click player below to hear.
Updated On: 10/16/11 at 07:23 PM