I can't believe there are people online talking about how "great" and "wonderful" this show is. This scares me. Theater is only as awful as the people who allow it to continue and the fact that anyone enjoyed this show just encourages more people to put more crap on the boards.
However, since according to Walt you're not allowed an opinion without some sort of fact to back it up, let me try to go through what's wrong with the show point by point:
1. Hugh Panaro, the actor. I love Hugh and he's one of the dearest people you'll ever meet, but his acting (or lack thereof) is God awful. Some people are meant to look and sound pretty. Hugh's one of them. Leave the heavy lifting for somebody else, 'kay?
2. Bernie Taupin's lyrics. Ooph. I've written songs for over 15 years. If you're reading this, odds are good you've never heard any of them. Why? Because most of them aren't really that good. Having said that, I'm pretty confident I could've written better lyrics than "I'm tired. I'm torn. This cruel wretched storm churns like a gale through my bones." We get the sailor motif Bernie, now how's about a little something that advances the plot or provides more than the most general insight into the character who's singing.
3. The opening of the show. Starting this show in the middle of the woods with a dead stuffed animal at Lestat's feet is NOT a good idea. Since the lyrics don't actually provide you with any plot advancement, the audience is left trying to figure out what's going on and why we should care. Okay, Lestat killed some wolves. Why is this important? Why's he singing about "the dead"? I thought he was a vampire, not a werewolf. Okay, now we're home and his dad's pretty pissed at him. Why? Were they his wolves? Why is their relationship so troubled...oh, wait. He's gone. Gabrielle tells him to go to Paris (I guess we're in France) because something out there "changed him". Is he already a vampire? Wait, that's still 10 minutes away...you get the idea.
4. The closing of the show. Actually, I think this is the most offensive part of the show. Lestat's got a couple of broken legs and the mythical Marius (who we're supposed to care about because...?) tells him to get up and then lets him feed while they rise on a platform. Judging by the deep sleep my ass is in, we must be at the end of the show. Okay, how about a big finale song to send us out? Wait. The lights are out. Is the show over? Should I be clapping? Oh, here's Lestat. He's in jeans and a red shirt (ooh, symbolism). What's he saying? He is the vampire Lestat. Right, kind of got that already. Oh, he's going to live forever. Well, good for him. I wonder if he's going to sing about living for-- oh, people are bowing.
For the love of God, please go back to the SF opening/closing of the show. From what I understand, Lestat at a laptop was pretty funny (unintentionally, of course), but it can't be any funnier than what they've changed it to. At least starting the show in modern times with Lestat announcing he's going to tell his story and finishing with him singing about how everything that's happened is what's going to give him the strength to go on provided some semblance of a story.
5. Songs that don't belong. At first, I thought Elton John's score was on the weak side, but out-of-context I find that it's actually sticking with me. Which says to me that these are songs that are good outside of the show they're in. The biggest offender here is "Sail Me Away". The song is beautiful (and Hugh sings the **** out of it), but it just doesn't fit the show and actually brings whatever momentum they actually had to a complete halt.
6. The "effects". As mentioned before, the fire in front of a performer on a platform thing is pretty easy to spot, as is the cirque du soleil that is Marius' entrance. They're just pretty cheesy, all in all.
Anyway, those are the things off the top of my head. Sorry for the length, but I didn't want to be accused of simply hating the show without anything to back it up (other than a credit card bill for two tickets that I'm sad I have to pay for).
Every passing minute is another chance to turn it all around...