Hey Baritone,
Although you have a differing opinion about Ms. Rice than I do, I'm glad you raised your voice in her defense. Judgment of talent is a very subjective thing, and as you pointed out, neither Prince nor Sondheim seemed to object to her performance in ST.
I didn't care for it, and happened to enjoy Ms. Josyln more. But I don't think either Dollypop or I were "trashing" Ms. Rice, we were offering up an opinion (and one that wasn't particularly harsh, at that).
My personal opinion about Ms. Rice's talent notwithstanding, I stand by my theory that reviving LITTLE MARY SUNSHINE is a terrible idea. As much as I would like to see Alison Fraser tackle that role, a revival of the show would not work.
I'm not arguing the merits of LITTLE MARY SUNSHINE. (I happen to think that it's a terrific little musical.) But the fact remains that it is a spoof of an art form that contemporary audiences are wholly unfamiliar with.
To an extent, LITTLE MARY SUNSHINE works on its own merits. But the reason it had such a successful run originally was due to the fact that audiences recognized what it was gently spoofing. When you take away the tongue-in-cheek quotient, you have to accept it as a work of art on its own terms, and by comparison to successful operettas (i.e., THE NEW MOON, THE STUDENT PRINCE) it pales.
A revival of either THE NEW MOON or THE STUDENT PRINCE would be unthinkable today. Carrying this reasoning through, you have to agree that a revival of a show whose overriding purpose is to spoof operetta is an insane idea.
Updated On: 11/14/04 at 05:30 AM