I definitely believe you about Sutton overacting. I've seen her do it before - but I guess those triple threats can't be perfect in everything, lol. She's definitely a singer/dancer before an actress, that's for sure. And there's really little dancing in this show so she's really going to have to reach for the acting and work on that.
Haha, Maureen came out while I was talking to Sutton and sat down beside my mom... and at one point while Sutton was speaking to me, I glanced over and Maureen McGovern and my mom were just sitting there talking. Like they were old friends. It was... ridiculously strange. And my mother (whom I dragged with me to see it) had NO idea Maureen was in it until she came out on stage and she absolutely went crazy. So it was REALLY funny.
I think my thing with Amy was moreso her acting in the second act. I just felt her characterization was a little off.
How did you feel about Meg and Beth? I think Jenny Powers is terrific and insanely beautiful, but she got the usualy Meg treatment - sort of the pretty one and nothing else, you know? Megan McGinnis was a good Beth, but I'd like to see more development in her character in terms of being the shy one and the sickly one. Maybe a little more intensity surrounding her death? (But not overdone, of course. That would definitely weigh the show down.)
Ashley