Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

MACK & MABEL at Encores? — Page 2

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#26

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

^ Did Herman mention how he felt about Streisand having played Dolly when she was 27?
#27

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

As I said above, everyone I know who knows him says Herman isn't just nice, but genuinely kind. I'm sure he wasn't going to say Streisand was too old for the part.

It's not as if Streisand is actually going to compete with her younger self and remake the movie! Imagine the side-by-side shots on You Tube!

I don't know that Hawn looks 40, but she certainly looks great for her age when she gets done up. But let's at least agree we're going for "looks 40s" rather than "looks 66".

#28

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

henrik, Herman's never been shy about saying Streisand was far too young to be playing Dolly when she did the film. She was under contract by the studio and was their choice for Dolly, not Herman's. When talking about her in the piece I'm referring to, he said, "She's the perfect age now, but she's never coming back to Broadway."

In fact, Streisand felt she was far too young to be making the movie too, and she was adamant about not wanting to do it. She committed to film DOLLY before the film of FUNNY GIRL began production, and Ray Stark (who produced FUNNY GIRL and signed Streisand to a three picture deal) apparently threatened to pull her from the movie if she didn't agree to DOLLY too, since he was nervous he'd have trouble finding financing for FUNNY GIRL if Streisand went against a big studio without the clout to back it up. Famously, Stark would later use his contract with Streisand to force her into making FUNNY LADY, which may explain why she later became so fierce in her desire for creative control of her work.

And Gaveston, I completely agree. As I said, part of the many things that make Hawn so ideal is how she looks, not how old she really is.
Tonya Pinkins: Then we had a "Lot's Wife" last June that was my personal favorite. I'm still trying to get them to let me sing it at some performance where we get to sing an excerpt that's gone.
Tony Kushner: You can sing it at my funeral.

Updated On: 1/17/12 at 05:41 PM

#30

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

Thanks Somethingwicked, I thought it probably was something like that.
#31

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

Herman is a nice guy (or so I've heard), but he is very particular on the casting of his shows and how his songs are sung - which is why we haven't seen a MAME on Broadway since the 80's, because he says nobody can live up to Angela. He has also spoke openly about his dislike for the film but they needed a big name for it; Lucy Ball was the biggest name in showbiz at the time, and 3-time Oscar nominee Lansbury wouldn't cut it.

I'm actually surprised he didn't go in and tell Doug Hodge how to sing the songs the way they were written, though he probably forgave him like the rest of the world because Doug's performance was so brilliant.
#32

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

Much as I love the Parton, a wax-faced, huge-uddered Dolly from the hills of Kentucky would be an instant camp classic. That has the potential to be Broadway's hugest mistake ever.

And sweet old Goldie Hawn (who has had work done, no matter how much you love her), who hasn't performed a role on a live stage in - what? forever? - that just might have the second most potential to be Broadway's biggest mistake.
#33

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

True, newintown, but they do mention and refer to yonkers as a hick town MACK & MABEL at Encores?                               .
#34

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

And while we're on the subject of actors and their deceptions, the fact that Streisand NOW says she was too young to play Dolly (after everyone on the planet has already pointed it out) doesn't mean she actually thought that at the time. Actors have superpowers when it comes to self-deception and a juicy role.

That being said, I don't think the film is all that bad. Yes, Streisand's age lowers the stakes considerably: Horace Vandergelder is hardly her last chance and how long could 27-year-old Dolly have been married to Ephram Levi anyway?

Nonetheless, the musical number are often lively, the title song with Louie Armstrong is genius, and, if we're honest, Streisand herself was no more mannered than Michael Crawford.
#35

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

I love/hate Streisand's Dolly, but that's for another time. However, I have to say that she was persuasive, to me, as a woman much older than her 27 years. Perhaps not quite as someone of the ideal age for the role, but certainly as a well-preserved woman of early middle years.

Do we ever really know how old Ephraim Levy was, Gaveston? And, if so, why couldn't Dolly have married him quite young and at an age much younger than him, as girls, let alone young women, often did in that era?
#36

MACK & MABEL at Encores?

She could have, henrik. I don't know any reason why Dolly can't technically be 27.

But it sounds like she had an entire other life with Ephram, then a "second act" as a marriage broker, etc. If she's under thirty, she can't have spent long at either.

I basically agree with you, however. Although I understood the problem (lower stakes is the real issue since Streisand's Dolly has plenty of time left), it didn't bother me particularly when I first saw the film.

Frankly, I was far more bothered by Streisand's mannered acting which often borders on affectation. (I've already said Michael Crawford was no better.) It was the StreisandISMs (physical and vocal) that had me holding my sides with laughter; of course, we're all used to them now and I thought her schtick made more sense as Fannie Brice (which I happened to see after DOLLY!). In FUNNY GIRL I accepted Streisand's stuff as early 20th century ethnicity.

But you are right that she presents herself as a woman "of a certain age" and doesn't act too girlish. She's still too young, but HELLO, DOLLY! isn't in a class with horrible film adaptations like MAN OF LA MANCHA and CAMELOT.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71