Saw it today and rather enjoyed it! Metcalf is the reason to see this. She's just astonishing. She's hilarious, menacing, creepy. Everything you'd want. Willis is rather dead. His pain didn't feel real, which hurts the show and the story. I never truly felt bad for him. He seemed to be too in on the camp with a twinkle in his eye, whereas Metcalf committed herself.
The staging was interesting. I rather liked the set, and i loved the music. The beginning feels a little slow with the short snippets of scenes, and I missed some of the bits from the movie, like how Sheldon discovers that WIlkes has killed people before (doesn't he find newspaper clippings?). But still, I thought it was well done. I wish there was maybe a better way to show how isolated they were, but that's just nitpicky. It's totally worth seeing, at least for the famous "hobbling" scene.