I really like Maggie, and I want to see more of her. Part of me wanted to dislike her because she's so over the top, but it's so perfect for Maureen. Her energy and presence are just incredible.
I agree about her surpassing Idina, I actually really like Idina's voice, but on the OBCR she sounds like she's screeching. It makes Take Me Or Leave Me really hard to listen to.
And it helps that this lesbian likes cute-round-faced girls.
"A wonky eye, you've got my friend."