I've seen Mandy multiple times as Angelica, and every time, she is the weak link in the cast for me. "Satisfied" is no longer a heart-wrenching showstopper; it's just a song that Angelica sings (and slightly struggles with the fast raps). MyLife got it right when saying she "winked and gestured" a lot, which is a bizarre character choice for Angelica, who should be personifying charisma, elegance, innate brilliance. "It's Quiet Uptown" wasn't profound and emotional; it was just Angelica stepping out to start the next song. As talented a performer as I think Mandy is, I have really, really not enjoyed her take on Angelica, and hope her next project comes sooner than later.
Edit: A friend of mine who had never seen/listened to Hamilton before saw the show a couple of months ago, with Mandy as Angelica. During our conversation, I asked her, "Isn't 'Satisfied' amazing?," and she had to genuinely ask me, "Which character sang that again?" When you had Renée or even Alysha Deslorieux as Angelica, "Satisfied" was one of, if not the standout performance of the entire show. Mandy just isn't memorable in this role, and memorability is the essence of Angelica.
Updated On: 8/21/17 at 11:25 AM