I second Bat Boy... you can do it with 10 and its a great and fun show, especially for a college aged group.
Stand-by Joined: 7/28/07
"Working" by Steven Schwartz (and james taylor and others) is a great show for a small cast. Everyone can be showcased as all of the cast members double-up (or triple or more) in their roles. The casting info on mtishows.com says its for 11 (8 women, 6 men) but i think it can work with even fewer people by doubling up on more parts, or variations on the number of men/women mentioned there. its extrememly flexible in casting. some minor roles can even be changed to the other gender if necessary. look at it!
Shelter
Triumph Of Love
Inner City
It seems like I saw Chess at a dinner theatre with a very small cast.
I'd also third (or fourth or whatever it is by now) Romance, Romance. I never saw it other than the little bit that was on the Tonys, but I absolutely adore the score.
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/20/05
Romance, Romance is a delightful little show that played in 1989 (I think). It was up against Phantom that year, I believe, and got lost in the crunch. However, it had several nominations, including Best Musical. It's two one-act musicals, with four performaners in each and the same people double in both casts. It has a nice score.
"Assassins can be done with 11"
Is that the 'Butt Pirate' version?
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/28/05
You could probably do "Piazza" with 10 people.
Here's a few not mentioned and might be good for you, as they're not frequently done all over the place.
No Way to Treat a Lady (Cast of 4) An off-broadway musical about a cop and a serial killer using each other to gain notoriety and fame. 1 Woman plays both lead characters' mothers as well as every murder victim.
Ruthless!: (Cast of 6) Off-broadway musical about a young girl who wants to be famous so badly that she kills everyone who stands in her way.
Hedwig and the Angry Inch: (Cast of 2 and onstage band) Concert style show that chronicles the life of a trans-sexual east german rock star.
I Sing! (cast of 5) Examines the intertwined lives and relationships of 5 gen-xers
Chorus Member Joined: 6/17/06
Thrill Me(Cast of 2)
http://www.thrillmethemusical.com/
Passion could be done with 10 with doubling I think (or with a few actors in very small cameo roles for the one scene). I think we cut one of the soldiers when we did it. Very intimate show. Also very challenging for a director.
Spelling Bee is a small cast. Nine roles, not including audience spellers and if you always have the spellers playing the parents etc.
Videos