Saw SIX last (Friday) night. I sat (rear) Mezzanine, Row E, Seat 6 (more on that in a little bit). The young man in the next to last row of front mezzanine ahead of me was waving his hands, mouthing/singing? along, smiling from ear to ear, practically dancing in his seat during the show. He was clearly living his best life. Based on the frequent loud applause and verbal shows of approval throughout the show, he apparently wasn’t alone.
My experience was a little more muted. It’s a fun show for sure and I had a good time, but I’m glad I bought one of the cheaper seats ($99 = $113.70 with fees). I sat next to a guy and his girlfriend. After the show, I asked him what he thought and he also said it was fun, but he was glad they didn’t spend more on their seats.
As has been said a gazillion times, it’s basically an eighty-minute pop concert. Nothing wrong with that. The ladies all have remarkable voices. Abby Mueller (Jane Seymour) was out, but Mallory Maedke was great. In fact, she was one of my favorites. My other favorite was Brittney Mack (Anna of Cleves).
Now the things that muted my appreciation a notch. I’ve been to some amazing pop concerts (Madonna, Janet Jackson in her heyday, Katy Perry, Britney Spears, etc.) with spectacular stage designs, etc. While none of those ladies can match this cast’s powerhouse vocals, the show itself invites comparisons to those pop concert extravaganzas and at least for me (and probably just for me), it comes up just a tad short on that mark. It’s a small show comparatively so it was never going to be able to compete with those pop spectacles although the stage design is fun and certainly fits the show. That wouldn’t matter so much if it hit all the hallmarks of great musical theater.
But for me it’s missing at least a couple elements I consider crucial for great music theater. Even though there is at least one ballad (Heart of Stone) amidst the uptempo songs, for me it doesn’t possess the peaks and valleys that are integral for me when appreciating any great musical. By peaks and valleys, I mean tone and mood-wise, not necessarily tempo The peaks and valleys add extra resonance and nuance and depth to the show. This felt like it stayed on the same mood and (high!) energy level the whole time. Hamilton benefits from having both You’ll Be Back and My Shot, both Alexander Hamilton (the song) and It’s Quiet Uptown, both Non-Stop and Burn. Ditto for Wicked: both Popular and I’m Not That Girl, both The Wizard and I and Defying Gravity. Ditto for those pop concerts I mentioned. This instead feels like an 80-minute sugar rush. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, but like eating a big bag of gummy bears, you are really only getting one flavor profile (SUGAR!) and you probably won’t find it very filling afterwards even though it was fun while you were chomping their little heads off with your teeth.
I think this relates to the other thing that stopped me from being that guy in front of me in the front mezzanine: I never felt a real connection to the queens. The songs of course are not designed to move the plot along. They’re mostly there for each queen to tell her story in 3 to 7 minutes. But, for me, it felt like we were being told what happened without the benefit of showing it or getting a sense of each queen’s interior life.
I know that a lot has been said about Six being a big contender for best musical score at the Tony’s because it’s one of the few musicals with original music in a year filled with jukebox musicals. That’s likely true, but I don’t know if how original some the songs are. Each song/queen is meant to evoke certain pop divas, but sometimes it seemed a bit like copyright infringement. (Destiny Child’s Survivor, anyone?) The songs are certainly catchy. In fact, I must’ve been quite the sight while I was waiting for my hotel shuttle after I got back to the Secaucus train station. Ear buds in, stomping my feet, moving to the beat. I can’t recall if Sing Street is eligible for best original score, but if it is, I could see it or Flying Over Sunset giving SIX a big run for the money. I also don’t know if I see this winning Best Musical, but it’s certainly possible.
All of this makes it seem like I had a lot less fun time than I actually did. I just think the hype for this show raised my expectations to levels it couldn’t quite meet. I don’t see me trying to see it again. I love sugar, but I don’t eat Sour Patch Kids everyday.
Clearly I’m in the minority though based on the enthusiastic audience last night and avid fan repeat business. As I was making my way out of the theater, I overheard a lady commenting to her companion that she wasn’t sure how long they can keep attracting new ticket buyers. That’s not a concern - they have an avid fan base doing crazy repeat business plus lots of buzz. Make no mistake about it - this is a big fat hit.
Another note about the fans. The ushers (who were awesome last night) were talking to me before the show and one of them said the fans sometimes take a bunch of the playbills when they’re not looking. Some nights, this results in them having to tell the last people to be seated that they have run out of playbills. We discussed what people would hope to gain by taking a stack of playbills. The usher wondered if they are selling them on eBay. Seems unlikely, but I guess it’s possible. Maybe they’re grabbing them for friends who aren’t there and possibly hoping to get them all signed at stage door. Who knows?
Regarding my seat, I bought it because it was comparatively cheaper than most of the other seats in the theater and because on the seat map, it looked like it might be on the side aisle. Well, there is no side aisle. The seat abuts the wall of the stairwell. There is no wall in front though. Just a half curtain thankfully because without that there would not have been much legroom. I was able to dangle my long legs under the curtain. I must’ve been quite the sight. One of the ushers asked me if I was going to be okay. He said he could talk to the house manager about moving me to a jump seat. I wasn’t sure what that view would be like and I loved the view from my seat so politely declined as long as it was okay to dangle my legs during the show. He said that was fine. He also said if I changed my mind before the show begin to let him know. Still a relatively good bargain.
Also, one more note about the audience. I didn’t see anybody standing and dancing during the show which I was relieved about. And maybe it’s because there were only the three of us in our row but I didn’t see any distracting behaviors around me. Even the guy in front mezzanine wasn’t annoying to me because he was clearly having such a good time and the pop concert vibe encourages his behavior.
Before the show, I bought the magnet, program, and the “I’m The Queen of the Castle” t-shirt.
Updated On: 3/1/20 at 05:16 PM