Well, the show didn't show much of any of the portrayals...we saw the production numbers and a few bits of dialogue, but that's it...nothing to form a complete portrayal from.
I will say, however, I though Hilty handled all of the musical numbers brilliantly.. And in her defense, she got the flashy Marilyn numbers that played heavily on her persona, not "Never Give All The Heart" (ok, she did get it, but it was a shortened version), and even then, that was really the only emotional musical number Kat got, and I didn't really get "intimate" or "vulnerable" from it.
Hilty also got the bits of dialogue, which fully displayed her vulnerability. There was the monologue about not wanting to be "a thing", and the brief scene with JFK, which I found to be pretty brilliant. And "Secondhand White Baby Grand" speaks for itself.
I also prefer Hilty's "Don't Forget Me"--she found a way to elevate the song to a whole other level. Katherine has an amazing voice, and it was a triumph for her character, but I felt Hilty not only sang it well, but acted it well...
But then again, Kat didn't have all of the musical numbers/scenes that Megan did, but I'm just going by what I saw and thought.
Updated On: 6/25/15 at 12:16 AM