I would agree with what's been said here: Front of balcony > Rear of mezzanine. I've seen a number of Encores shows and can support this statement wholeheartedly for a number of reasons:
(1) The front of the balcony overhangs Grand Tier Row E (http://www.nycitycenter.org/getattachment/Home/Visitor-Info/Seating-Maps/seatmap-mainstage.pdf.aspx), so you really don't feel that far back.
(2) The incline of the balcony is so steep, you actually feel like you have more legroom since your feet are touching the top of the seat in front of you.
(3) The sight lines from the balcony aren't too cut-off, which is surprising given how high up you are. Plus, Encores shows don't do too much (if anything) high in the air, so you really won't miss much.
I've always sat in the cheap seats for Encores shows (the closest row and the furthest center a $25 seat can buy in the balcony!), and you can usually move down/in once the show starts given that selling out NY City Center is difficult. Of course the sucky thing about the balcony is that the only entrance to a row is on eihter side, which means latecomers can be really disruptive to a lot of people if they are sitting in the center.
On the same topic, however, I actually have my own question about Encores seating, for future reference. I'm seeing "The Wild Party" in July, and at the time of purchase, the $25 seat options I had were either the orchestra pit seats (Rows AA, BB, and CC) or the far sides of the front row of the Grand Tier (e.g. Row A, Seat 15). I chose to sit in the latter, but I'm not sure I made the right choice.
Does anyone have experience with either seating area? I was afraid the orchestra pit seats would be too close to the stage (I'm pretty sensitive about being too close -- my rush ticket seat in the first row of the Walter Kerr made "Gentleman's Guide" a terrible theater experience.)
Updated On: 6/25/15 at 12:10 PM