New Phantom Of The Opera Movie (2004)- Page 2

[Theatreboy33]

Posted: 10/23/03 at 9:02pm

roscoe, i like your brutal honesty about things. i chuckled at the sad reality behind both this message and your review of Nine from last night. nonetheless, i think ill agree with you about this film, though i still encourage people to see it for the sake of keeping the interest in musicals up.

[BillyLawlor]

Posted: 10/24/03 at 12:04am

Glenn CLose would have been great, but my first choice was Donna Murphy. SHe defines Madame Giry in my opinion, but oh well. The only I thing I saw Richardson in was "Alice In WOnderland" and I really can't judge how great she'll be from her disgustingly high and squeaky voice. I was also looking forward to seeing Alan Cumming. Oh well- I'm sure the movie will be great. The only reason I am looking forward to Minnie Driver as Carlotta is because I loved her voiceover work in "Tarzan"-lol.

[ruthiefan_felix]

Posted: 10/24/03 at 5:37am

Hi,
I have also seen Miranda Richardson in Alice. She is fit .... for Carlotta. She has those Carlotta feel, always screaming, shouting and fussing all around... But I am quite prepared that the movie will disappoint me. I REALLY hope that Hugh Jackman can be Phantom!!!!!!!! But hopeless now!!! I hope that this POTO movie will not suck like CHICAGO the movie!!! *cries and disappointed*
My CHICAGO the musical group!