I caught this last week, and I apologize for the delay in reporting my thoughts.
After reading the thoughts of those who have seen it in this thread, I was actually pleasantly surprised. I went in expecting something of a trainwreck, and actually ended up enjoying myself. I found the performances to be pretty solid all around - especially Jillian van Niel as Evelyn Nesbit. The orchestra was disappointing with its minimalism, but the vocals of the cast were very good, especially for a relatively small ensemble. The house was maybe around 3/4-ish full, which I feel is good for a non-eq tour of a show that hasn't been on Broadway in half a decade. The acting was good, and though the set was minimal I feel that it worked. The original can never be matched, but I would recommend this production, especially to people who are unfamiliar with the show and won't know what they're missing from the original. 6.5/10