Saw it Monday December 18th and it was hands doen the worst performance of a Broadway show I have ever seen.
Howar was all over the place. At times he was speaking(yelling is more like it) to the wrong character. Vocally he seems to have either been just getting over a cold, damged his voice, or just a bad singer. His stifling his natural British accent gave any of his spoken lines an odd cadence which didn't help his characterization Hanke seemed to be trying something different in each scene and then abandoning it in the next. There seemed to be a certain level of dis-interest from him which maybe was his way of "Detach(ing) form being alive" . Regardless it came across as ambivalence.
I saw the Marueen cover and thought she was great, although She seems like she is a bit of a square peg in this show. She seems better suited for contmporary sweet ingenue stuff instead of Brassy character stuff like maureen. That being said she did a very good job Joanne was OK, although She didn't seem to me like a HArvard educated lawyer.
Collins seemed about ten years older than The other collins's i ahve seen. HE riffed on I'll cover you to sing a high note and it only caused me to lose the emotion of the song-not a great choice.
I have seen the show 4 times and know it quite well. I haven't been back in a few years and was actually really excited since all the other times I saw it the creative team and the casting people were always filling it with new (but Talented) blood making it always fresh. Even my sister in law who loves rent but doesn't know much about Musical theater thought it was horrendous.
ANgel hands-down stole the show
Mimi was good. Angel was
The dancing wa a mess and the singing was marginal
Other than that, did you enjoy the play Mrs Lincoln?