alright, while it's not my favorite by any means, i adore this show--i think it has wonderful things to say, it has spoken and continues to speak to me on many levels, the music is FUN, i love the sets, costumes, etc. i'm a member of the "young & hip" crowd--i'm not one who is old or doesn't get the show, blah blah. I think it's a fantastic piece of art that DID influence a generation. HOWEVER, i too agree that it's time to close the show or do a major overhaul. I never saw the original cast, so all the rent heads can't play that card here. I've seen various tours since i became familiar with the show in 1998, and I only recently made my first trip to the nederlander to see the show "on broadway!!" I was crazy excited to see it, and was SEVERELY let down. each of the tours (I think I've seen 5 or 6 tour performances) i've seen were leaps & bounds better than the broadway production...and that includes the non-equity tour that was out recently. (i dont have my playbill in hand, so if i'm getting the names wrong, please dont flame too much) I've never seen an entire cast, save one performer, phone in or walk thru a performance--it was bleak. Matt Caplan was barely passable as Mark, Andy Senor was HORRENDOUS as Angel--sure he could hit the notes & sure he could jump on the table & sure he looked fabulous in the costumes, but there was absolutely no emotion to anything he did--did not make me buy his Angel for one second...and i wanted to!!...listen, the boy did not ONCE (believe me, i paid attention), not ONE TIME crack a smile or do anything to make us believe he was having a good time. I try to give people the benefit of the doubt--i left the theater saying that his portrayal of Angel was either wildly brilliant or the worst performance i've ever seen in any show ever. i dotn recall the names of the rest of the performers (none were memorable) other than Krystal Washington, who was Mimi. She was working her ass off & was doing a great job, IMO. I had seen her on the non-eq tour and was blown away. there was no energy to the show, obvious line & lyric flubs all over the place, choreography was not tight...i left wishing that i could get those 2.5 hours of my life back, and thinking that i was REALLY glad i had used a discount coupon. i wouln't have recommeded the broadway production to anyone...AND THIS COMING FROM SOMEONE WHO LOVES THE SHOW!! perhaps if a person has never seen the show before, what is currently being performed at the nederlander is great, but otherwise, IMO, it's completely unacceptable.
sort of sorry for the long & somewhat rambling post, but someone was asking for a more detailed reason on why Rent should close in New York. Hope this helps. :)
"I'll eat some breakfast then change the world."
"I hate you, and I hate your ass face!"