I believe that critics do not usually come back to re-review a show unless invited back by the producers. Producers don't usually re-invite the press unless they are looking for the press associated with the new reviews, so it will usually only happen if there is a major cast replacement.
The only exception I can think of is if there is some special feature -- for example, I recall the NYT doing a "re-review" of some of the big hits (Phantom, Les Miz, Miss Saigon) many years back as part of a feature on long-running shows.
"This is wanting something, this is reaching for it,
This is wishing that a moment would arrive.
This is taking chances, this is almost touching, what the beauty is." --The Light in the Piazza