One of my favorites, too. I even did that fan thing and went closing night -- which was stirring and then some.
I think it's terrific that high schools are finding this material. It's actually a very tasteful show, not full of tacky double-entendre. And the music just lifts it. The only sections tricky to make seem sufficiently adult: "Private Conversation," which really requires a very vulnerable, manly side of Terry ... and of course, "Tunnel of Love,"which has challenging notes and almost becomes maudelin if not done with total conviction. For this show to work, you cannot back away from the size of the emotion--the emotion carries it, not the so-called subject matter. It's a beautiful love story, and I don'tcare what John Lahr thought (famously) in the New Yorker about "I Will Never Leave You" -- to me, the irony of it being sung by two sisters who cannot part makes it simply heart-rending. I get teary thinking of the verse... ("...if we stood on our tiptoes, we could see a girl walking up the hill ... and we'd think what a sad situation, to go through life with no playmate, to go through life all alone...") Cynics, back off. It's heartfelt stuff. Brava to the ambitious drama teacher!
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling