I'm currently playing in the pit for a production of SCROOGE: The Musical in Snug Harbor in Staten Island. I talked to one of the cast members about how interesting the dance numbers were. I found out that the dancing in that (particularly in Fezziwig's "December the 25th" and Tom Jenkins' "Thank You Very Much") is much like Pinaud interpreted it. The dresses are too long and too wide to skip, hop and jump in (this is DICKENS!!!), so the girls hold up the skirts so they won't trip.
Pretty much the same thing can be said with DROOD, if anybody agrees with me. I know I've seen it in the opening scene of THE WEDDING SINGER, because much of the dresses of the '80s were so poofy (not to mention incredibly ugly to some people) that it was so tough to line-dance in.
In fact, Pinaud is TOTALLY right. If it looks appropriate for the number or period, then they should definitely use it. Also, I must agree with CurtainPullDowner, because the choreographer needs to ask the costume designer what they're going to be wearing because that's what makes it looks good. Depends: if you're going to use something with a lot of leg work in it (like Fosse), the costume is going to have to be pantlike or miniskirtlike. And if the costume is very long, wide, or spinny (like in OKLAHOMA or MEET ME IN ST. LOUIS or MUSIC MAN or something along those lines), it makes perfect sense to swish it around.
Anybody else want to discuss what they have done and/or seen (especially if it's the same show).
"How could she just suddenly, completely disappear into thin water?" - The Little Mermaid