Spring Awakening OBC Signed Window Card

My boyfriend and I were going through some things when we noticed this old window card that we had forgotten about. We're about to move and money is a little tight so I took to Google to find out how much we might could get out of this thing. It's not in the best condition but is signed by the entire original Broadway cast of the musical.

The prices listed on Ebay for something similar but in perfect condition was as much as 700 dollars, which honestly took me by surprise. I hadn't hoped to get more than 100 bucks out of it. We're not entirely sure about selling it, but if we did I'd like to know what would be a good price for it. If anyone on this forum could help me out in figuring out what this is worth I'd be much obliged!

It was hanging on my wall for a while by thumbtacks and the back has yellowed with age. Other than that, it's fine. 

If it's only thumbtack holes and the corners are not dulled and the edges are clean and crisp, I'd list it at $175. That's if it is the black poster with the full credits on the bottom. If it's the other black poster without credits or the white poster, maybe $100 - $125. 

I didn't take it as defensive at all, just a clarification on the condition. 

Which is exactly what I was trying to do! haha

Thanks for the info. It does have the credits on the bottom, but one corner is pretty rough compared to the rest of it. I got a little excited when I found the Ebay listing for it, but I did feel like 700 bucks was a little pricey! Would one in perfect condition be worth that much?

Wish we had taken better care of this thing now! Drat!

After really looking it over I noticed there's a small tear on the top and there's a couple spots on the side that look less than perfect. But if anyone's interested or wants to make an offer for this thing, I'd be willing to sell it. 

If something is listed for $700 on eBay, the reason you are still seeing it is because it isn't selling at that price (unless you are searching completed listing only, which is a more accurate measure).

Just out of curiosity, how much would a brand new still in the plastic covering copy of

Spring Awakening In the Flesh go for?