Just got back from the show. First thing I wanted to do when I got out was I wanted to get tickets to see it again.
The projections were breathtaking, but because of this, I missed out on some of the acting moments. It's one of those things that it seems you have to watch twice because there is so much to look at (in such a small space really) that you are bound to miss out on some things.
Hugh Panaro did not impress me during his stint as Bobby in "Company" at the 5th Ave, so I wasn't coming in expecting too much from him, but he actually was pretty good when he wasn't trying to channel Mandy (which, invariably is hard to do in any production of Sunday, I suppose). He seems to have this dichotomy between his head voice and his chest voice that I don't completely like either, but he did an admirable job, though I was afraid he was going to lose it a couple of times during "Putting it Together" (he messed up "Being Alive" when I saw him in "Company"). He does LOOK good as George in Act II, though.
Billie Wildrick I didn't like as Dot in Act I. She seemed to sing too sweetly and didn't seem to connect with Georges as much as she should have. I was comparing her a lot with Bernadette's portrayal a lot, so it may have clouded my judgment a little. But I loved her in the second act as Marie (it was cute that she gave Marie a little southern drawl, since her mother was taken to America). She did seem to get some of the rhythms of "Children And Art" off though.
I still teared up a little during "Sunday" and "Move On".
I am glad that Seattle did get this production (the entire production, as during the talkback after the show, almost everything was from the New York Production, and that the show is not going on tour due to having to adjust all the projections, which took a process of 10 days), and if you are in the Seattle area, make sure you catch it.
Now all the 5th Ave. needs to do is Merrily, Passion, and Anyone Can Whistle and we would have seen almost all the major Sondheim shows.
Xanadu! Can't cry on cue!