Yankee is correct, Danielm. While most of the productions Mantello has touched have turned to gold, it's usually in one way or another. Either they are huge artistic achivements (Love, Valour..., Assassins, Blackbird) or they are huge commercial achievements (Three Days of Rain, Wicked, The Odd Couple). Very rarely is it both with Mantello. Although there are plenty who think that he was never that inspiring a director. Like every person in the arts, he has his fans and his haters.
Although, it must be said, no matter what the outcome of his productions he still manages to be one of biggest go-to directors on Broadway right now (2 Tony Awards in the last 4 years will do that). Looking forward to this revival, if anything to see Rosie Perez in it.
"Sing the words, Patti!!!!" Stephen Sondheim to Patti LuPone.