I was there too last night -- we got out about 10:20 I think. Maybe a little earlier. I was stuffing my face at Burritoville by about 10:30 I think.
I have to say that I think you got it dead on Ruprecht. (Love the avatar, by the way!) Orfeh looked GREAT in her long wig...and we may have heard it before, but she truly brings down the house with those pipes. I overheard some women on the elevator complimenting her voice and saying that she reminded them of Jerry Hall. (I see it - it's all about glamour and lips!)
The trio of trailer park ladies get the really fun stuff in the show and all three are fantastic. Wayne Wilcox also gives it his all. He's really got the crazy-eye thing down. lol.
Shuler is so reminiscent of John Goodman in his Dan Conner days that it's perfect! (Possible star casting for the Vegas version??) The set is also crazy-cool and the production overall was in really good shape for the first perf.
While I loved Kaitlin Hopkins in Bare and Bat Boy, the agorophobia plotline kind of ties her to the trailer (heh) and makes her numbers kind of blur together a little bit in this. You're right, Rup, that maybe giving that one song just to Orfeh would break it up a little. (I'd also venture to say one more could be cut, but don't kill me Kaitlin fans! Also, CUT THAT STUPID T-SHIRT SHE WEARS THE WHOLE SHOW. I didn't get the joke and it was distracting.)
Overall, I think I wanted the relationship between Orfeh/Shuler to be explained a little more. You don't really get to see why they are drawn to each other -- it just kind of happens. Does he just think she's really hot? Does he want to help her hide? Does she choose him? Is it just right place/right time? Maybe she should do her strip number directly to him. Who knows. Now I'm rambling, but I see such potential here! I'd like to hear what other people think as they see it.