I'm gonna be perfectly honest, as is my trademark on these boards.
Taye Diggs is not a star. He certainly deserves to be but he is not. Idina Menzel is not a star. She certainly deserves to be but is not. A star couple is the pairing of Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick. The kind of coupling that has people lining to streets to buy tickets that sell out a 4 month run. To think that the producers of Wicked would put Diggs in hoping for that kind of reaction is ludicrous and hardly any sort of an argument. I have to agree with whomever suggested it was done as a favor. Idina I wouldn't doubt, suggested her husband.
The show is an advanced sales hit so far and its not like they needed a semi-star to lift it. The Producers (musical) need two stars to stay afloat.
Give Diggs time, all actors must grow into their characters. I actually feel bad that he was so badly rushed into this.
As for those fabricated offstage quotes, Wicked must have the most unfaithful, disloyal sort of ensemble on Broadway because there is an unwritten code that was violated. Now I don't think that is the case which is why those quotes are fabricated.
I'm right. I'm a Republican
BSoBW2: I punched Sondheim in the face after I saw Wicked and said, "Why couldn't you write like that!?"