I am one of those who did not love the show but I definitely love the recording. Sondheim's score sounds wonderful. Numbers that got lost in the choreography, like the First Act closer, "Frogs", sound amazing on the CD. Ditto the "Hymn to Dionysus" which had little effect on stage. Nathan and the cast shine, although Roger Bart isn't really the answer to the Xanthius problem - maybe it wasn't all Chris Kattan's fault, there truly isn't much to the role.
Faced with these Loreleis, what man can moralize!