If you want to go for a more Broadway-rock feel, you could consider some selections from Footloose- Mainly:
Somebody's Eyes
Holding out for a Hero...(If you want to showcase your own voice more, Overthemoon)
Featured Actor Joined: 6/3/05
Yeah, "Hero" and "Somebody's Eyes" from Footloose are catchy, and also look at stuff from Dreamgirls- "Move" or many of the others could work
"angels arise" from DOTV is good.
woman in white also has a great trio for girls. i'm not sure of the title, but it's in the first act.
Videos