#76
Posted: 9/4/08 at 8:19pm
Among most recent shows it would have to be XANADU. In all honesty, I didn't expect much as I saw the execrable film on which it is based, which itself was a rip-off of a superior 1947 musical film, starring Rita Hayworth, called DOWN TO EARTH. But I gave in to the pressure of some friends who were dying to see it (and thankfully paid for my ticket). My worst fears were realized as the stage musical surpasses the film by leaps and bounds in mediocrity and that is saying a lot. Also, I found Kerry Butler’s performance and voice to be extremely annoying, hardly how one should react to an actress playing a muse. Although no better an actress but a far more talented singer, Olivia Newton-John at least had charisma which made the film less painful in this respect. Cheyenne Jackson was not any more appealing, although to be fair this kind of material could make anyone seem vapid. Most disappointing was Jackson’s singing, which was about as generic as any 1990’s boy band singer. I suspect that without the aid of the excessive miking employed, Jackson, Butler or any of the performers voices would not project past the stage lights, but again to be fair that is a criticism that could be leveled against the majority of today’s Broadway singers. XANADU might have been more tolerable with no sound at all.