Which show should I rush tomorrow?? (Finding Neverland, An American in Paris, Matilda)

I want to surprise one of my friends tomorrow with some tickets and I was wondering which show would be the most visually exciting? My friend is from another country and her english isn't TERRIBLE, but I don't want to bore her to death with a show that is somewhat like Curious Incident (amazing show, but could be difficult to understand). Also, which show would I have the best chance of getting rush tickets for?? Thank you!!

I would advise against Matilda is she has trouble understanding english. It is a very visually pleasing show, but there are lots of complex lyrics and children who can be difficult to understand. I'll second what the other poster said about American in Paris, if she likes dancing. If she's not very into dancing, I would definitely suggest Finding Neverland.

I would also suggest Neverland for a non primary English speaker. Much as I like Matilda, it has a lot of words and a intricate plot to follow. American in Paris is great with the dancing but if you are not into dancing, it's a long show. Neverland is a big hit with most tourists who come but yes you can only get one rush ticket per person. (Plus Tony Yasbeck is great).