Which shows are these from?

This may be a bit of a weird question, but oh well, it's worth a shot...



Does anyone know from which shows these are? Whenever something is blown into the audience or if something falls from the sky, I take one of those goodies with me as a memento (unless it's a Spider-Man actor). I usually label them - no kidding - but now I found these three unlabeled ones and I really can't remember which shows had these.

They're definitely from a NY show, most likely Broadway, that played anywhere between 2009 and 2012. The red one is definitely not from First Date. I keep thinking Follies for the pink and / or red ones but I'm not sure. The feather, I have no idea at all.

Major props to anyone who can help me out!

I had a look at the list of shows that I saw during that period and removed the ones where these goodies are definitely not from. Ended up with this list (unless I overlooked something):

Mamma Mia
The Story Of My Life
West Side Story
Shrek The Musical
Billy Elliot
9 to 5: The Musical
La Cage Aux Folles
Bye Bye Birdie
Hair
Finian's Rainbow
A Little Night Music
The Miracle Worker
Promises, Promises
Lend Me A Tenor
Sondheim On Sondheim
Everyday Rapture
Women On The Verge Of A Nervous Breakdown
A Little Night Music
Elf
Spider-Man: Turn Off The Dark
Catch Me If You Can
Anything Goes
Priscilla: Queen Of The Desert
Arcadia
How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying
Wonderland: A New Alice
Sister Act
The Book Of Mormon
Follies
The Mountaintop
Godspell
Harvey
The Fantasticks
Newsies
Evita

Nothing is from Newsies or Mamma Mia!.

That feather immediately made me think of Falling.

The rose petals make me think they're from Follies, too. Unsure about the feather.

The rose petal could also be from Godspell.