I'm from a different era, but I would like to give my choices. I've broken them down into categories. I'm sure that if I saw some of these performers today I would find them old fashioned, but in my youth they were highly palpable stage presences.
Best Dranatic Actress: Katharine Cornell
Best Comic Actress (not slapstick or outrageous): Shirley Booth tied with Rurh Gordon
Best Musical Actress: Vivienne Segal
Best Dramatic Actor: Paul Muni
Best Comic Actor: Joseph Cotten
Best Musical Actor: William Gaxton
Best Broadway Dancer (Female): Libby Bennett
Best Broadway Dancer (Male): Duke McHale
Dancer with the loudest laugh: Me!!!!!!
Miriam
Every movement has a meaning--but what the hell does it mean!