I saw the production in Berlin and I'd love for it to come to Broadway, but with a new set design. I got really bored with blocks and projections after the first 15 minutes or so. The only scene that impressed me visually was the interior of Notre Dame during God Help the Outcasts. The costumes were wonderful, especially the gargoyles, which could have been irritatingly cheesy, but looked absolutely stunning.
Drew Sarich was perfect, though there were a few odd directing choices. For example, Out There was almost entirely performed while on his knees. It looked really awkward. And Topsy Turvy was choreographed with a distinct German bent based on a popular folk dance, so it looked more odd and simplistic to me than to the average German audience.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian