I saw it twice on Broadway. The first time... GREAT! The second time (over a year later)... not so much.
The cast and their chemistry with the audience as well as each other is critical. It's everything actually.
This is a British "saloon" show. A "Music Hall."
It's all about the personalities on stage and how they interact and connect with the audience.
If you can assemble a killer (no pun intended) cast, you've got it made.
But the cast was tired when I saw it the second time (with Donna Murphy, Karen Morrow and a very tired George Rose), and it was really in need of Geritol.
The first time with the full OBC, it was magic!
I think a revival would do very well with the right people in it.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22