Since the running joke is that Elphaba eventually starts to look more and more like the witch in the movie (cape, broom, hat, etc.), I think your best bet is to go for, well...black clothes, a cape, broom, hat, green makeup...
I'm creative, I know.
You're welcome. :)
"It's not always about you!!!" (But if you think I'm referring to you anyway, then I probably am.)
"Good luck returning my ass!" - Wilhemina Slater
"This is my breakfast, lunch and f***ing dinner right here. I'm not even f***in' joking." - Colin Farrell