When the show toured, it was re-directed by Joe Layton, not Ron Fields. And they gave Bacall a brand new title song. I've never heard it, but I wonder if it taxed her, uh, range.
To my ears, her best singing in the score is on a song called "I Wrote The Book..." Take a listen. It's a catchy Kander and Ebb song, the lyrics are witty, and most critically, she doesn't have to push, to create money notes with zero in the bank, i.e. to do those "But Alive" (and title song) screeches that are impossible to make sound musical. They wrote the show for her, and when she does the middle-range songs like "I Wrote the Book," she actually sounds pleasant. And elegant. She should never be made to hold a note. My guess is, the new title song somehow kept her from those top notes that sent Merman over the edge.
Over the years people have quibbled with my preference for Reynolds, but what made her work in the show was her effortless embrace of being a triple threat. The audience was comfortable, because Debbie was. And fact checkers (who will scramble to prove me wrong about Layton; I am pretty sure I'm right): if I'm correct, Reynolds got a new act one ballad, near the act curtain, but I can't find the title. Something like "Who Would've Known" but that's not it.
Of the two Bacall musicals, "Woman of the Year" had the superior score, song for song. I now find "Applause," title number excepted, third tier Strouse, and I'm a major fan of Charles Strouse ("Rags" a favorite). The "Woman" score pins down Tess as a character far better than "Applause" explicates the musical Margo Channing. Musically, "Woman's" of a piece, and it's just more sophisticated. Today, the rock-pop orchestrations that accompanied the Strouse songs for "Applause" sound unbelievably cheesy.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 8/27/12 at 06:23 PM