I love Bernadette, but seeing her in Gypsy was an anticlimax after hearing her on the CD. She seemed to have serious trouble with the diction, especially in the songs and the whole Mr. Goldstone scene. In Everything's Coming Up Roses, they almost dropped the entire curtain in three seconds lest she had to hold the note longer.
SHe was thrillingly stellar but her overall performance was not that great. Her Rose's Turn was better at the Tonys too.
I thought Kerry Butler was good in LSOH. I hated Michael Siberry in The SOund of Music (not that he's gifted) and he recorded the most painful Edelweiss ever!
The meat is always leaner on somebody else's dinner plate!