Just back from our NYC trip. Saw 7 shows in 6 days. I will give a brief review of each show we saw (in the order that we saw them).
As an aside, don't you guys think that having a "trip report" thread like this is a good idea? It keeps all the trip reports easily accessible, which I think would be very convenient for people trying to decide which shows to see.
Now, on with the countdown:
After Midnight - what a great way to start our trip. We had just found out shortly before we saw this that it was going to be closing soon, so we weren't entirely sure what to expect. Everyone in that cast was totally on point. This was the best band we've heard on Broadway in some time, and also some of the best dancing! Not to mention how incredible Patti was in the role of guest star. I still can't believe this is closing. I think it should run on Broadway for years, and if I lived anywhere near NYC I'd see it several times more.
If/Then - the least favorite of all 7 shows we saw on our trip. I love Idina (saw her in Wicked and in concert) and she was in fantastic voice, but that score was just so boring to us. I was really hoping for so much more....
Cabaret - I saw the last revival 2 different times, but this was my first time seeing Cumming in the role. I was so happy to finally get to see what all of the fuss was about. This was one of the best performances we saw on our trip. I'm also in the camp that Michelle nailed it as Sally. I am so glad that this is back, and it deserves another extended run.
Here Lies Love - this was my favorite production of the whole trip, and we didn't even get to see Ruthie. Her replacement was stellar (sorry I don't have her name, haven't unpacked my playbills yet). I loved every single song, I loved the concept, I loved the staging, I loved everything about this show. Did I mention that I LOVE Hear Lies Love?
Rocky - I liked this much more than I expected. For me, the set design alone was worth the price of admission, and I'm not talking about only the last ten minutes. I do realize that a couple of the songs fall flat, but I still don't understand why there's so much hate for this show. I found myself feeling more emotional watching this show than any other that we saw the entire week (except maybe Lady Day)
Finally, last night, the amazing double header (Lady Day at 8:00 PM, and Hedwig at 10:00 PM):
Lady Day - what can you say that hasn't already been said about this stupendous performance? I know that it is one that I will be talking about for years to come. Audra made me feel things that I had never felt at a show before. I felt such sadness and empathy for her. It was so realistic, I wanted to find her and comfort her after the show. I don't know how she does that night after night. Truly amazing.
Hedwig and the Angry Inch - extremely enjoyable. The funniest show that we saw the entire trip. NPH was as good as advertised, and the ending packed a great emotional punch.
All in all, this was one of our better trips to NYC in awhile, which actually seems ironic, after reading so much negative things about this past season. There are several shows that we will definitely revisit (Cabaret, Here Lies Love, and Lady Day, if it's still open).
BTW, if you try the Lady Day/Hedwig double header, I strongly recommend walking down 50th Street to 6th Ave, then walking from there to 44th. This was suggested to me in an earlier post, and I completely forgot about it in all the excitement. Slogging through Times Square at 9:45 is not a good idea, if you need to get anywhere in a hurry. We made it in time, but it was an adventure!
Updated On: 6/22/14 at 09:58 PM