I agree...it will be very hard for anyone to top Kelli O'Hara in this role in my book as well. She was absolutely radiant. I do hope you will give Ms. Wills another chance though. She was spectacular in "Wonderful Town" and "Beauty and the Beast". I can't comment on the two shows you saw since I didn't see them myself but I can't really imagine anyone really nailing the difficult character of Julie Jordan in a one week rehearsal period. I have never been that impressed with CLO shows myself. Anyway...everyone certainly has a right to their own opinions. It is going to be a difficult task to replace Ms. O'Hara indeed.