I absolutely adore "You Should Be Loved". The lyrics aren't wonderful, but that area leaves much to be desired throughout the entire show (although Side Show is a favorite of mine). The best part of the show to me was, and is, Norm Lewis. He just has a fantastic voice. And hey, who doesn't love a good baritone?
Harry's not my favorite actor, but I do enjoy his music. I first heard of him when he did the soundtrack for "When Harry Met Sally...". A great performer when it comes to standards, not sure how he'd do in a musical.