bway - there's no such thing as an "overall concensus" - especially here
That being said, though, I never really heard anyone say anything good about the play itself (critics or audience members.) I talked to some who were just happy to see Ms. Lansbury live onstage - and I got the impression it wouldn't have mattered what she was doing.
I know there were issues during previews, which as usual got blown out of proportion. Ultimately, it came off to me as a project that never really gelled - and I personally thought part of that was due to her non-committal performance. However, when the material is so sub-standard, rating a performance is kind of an exercise in futility.
Ms. Seldes, however, seemed to float above it somehow, and that kind of made Ms. Lansbury suffer by comparison.
edit - I really want to add that this is ONLY a comment on that particular piece - and ONLY in response to the idea that anyone can be without question. I saw Ms. Lansbury in SWEENEY TODD, and it was breath-taking!
Updated On: 5/11/08 at 10:13 AM